TibyānHSG®by IKIM
Grounded · Governed · Jurisdiction-aware

Is it Shariah-compliant?
Ask, and see the sources.

Describe any financial product and receive an AI-drafted assessment citing Bank Negara Malaysia, the Securities Commission, AAOIFI and other authorities — with an honest “inconclusive” when the sources don’t cover it.

AI generated draft — not a fatwa. Always consult a qualified Shariah advisor.
Answers grounded in
BNM SACSC MalaysiaAAOIFIOIC Fiqh AcademyDSN-MUIIFSBQuran & Sunnah
How it works

Three steps, no jargon

1

Describe the product

In your own words, or paste from a brochure. Pick your jurisdiction — Malaysia (BNM) is the default.

2

AI checks the sources

The system retrieves relevant rulings and standards, then drafts an assessment that cites only what it found. Nothing is made up: if the sources don’t cover your case, it says so.

3

Read, verify, escalate

Every citation names its document and resolution. Agree or unsure? Take the draft to a qualified advisor — we make that the next step, not an afterthought.


Why trust it

Trust is earned, line by line

Citations you can check

Every verdict names the standard, resolution, or verse it relies on. Citations are machine-restricted to real documents in our corpus — never invented.

Honest about disagreement

Where Malaysian and international authorities diverge, the answer says so — and leads with your selected jurisdiction — instead of pretending consensus.

Honest about limits

No relevant sources, no verdict. The system returns ‘Inconclusive’ rather than improvising an answer it cannot ground.

A draft, by design

Built for the human-in-the-loop: a watermark on every answer and a one-click path to a qualified advisor.

The proof

What an assessment looks like

“Personal financing of RM 50,000 through commodity tawarruq using crude palm oil…” Malaysia — BNM
Malaysia — BNMAI DRAFT
Evidence strength
Ẓann Ghālib
Strong probability — the working basis for most rulings
Shariah ruling
Mubāḥ
Permissible
Governance state
Valid with Conditions
Acceptable provided specified conditions are met and verified
Human authority
Escalate to scholar
A qualified scholar should decide
Summary

Personal financing structured on commodity tawarruq is permissible in principle under the Malaysian framework — but only with conditions, and its wider status is contested. The main caution is that the commodity sales must be real, not a paper formality.

Snapshot (5W1H)

A customer takes personal financing from an Islamic bank, which arranges a commodity purchase and onward sale (tawarruq) to deliver cash while avoiding an interest-based loan. This is current, widely-used practice in Malaysia and elsewhere. It matters because whether it is genuinely Shariah-compliant turns on whether the commodity legs are real and independently transacted — a fact that must be verified rather than assumed.

Quick answer
Answer
Permissible in principle under the Malaysian framework, but only if the commodity sales are genuine.
Governance status
Valid with conditions — pending verification.
Key reason
If the commodity legs are not real and independent, the arrangement can collapse into a disguised interest-bearing loan.
Main Shariah concerns & why

The central concern is that the mark-up could function as interest (riba) rather than profit on a real sale if the commodity legs are engineered by the same bank. A secondary concern is genuine possession (qabḍ) of the commodity — without it, the sale is form without substance.

What to check, and how

Obtain evidence of the actual commodity purchases and onward sales, the independence of the counterparties, and proof of genuine possession — and lead with your own jurisdiction's framework where authorities diverge.

Caution & practical advice

Do not market the product as fully Shariah-cleared until the commodity legs and counterparty independence are verified by a qualified reviewer. Escalate the structure to your Shariah committee before relying on it.

Substance over form
Riba“profit” on the commodity sale

If the commodity legs are not genuine, the mark-up can function as interest on a loan rather than profit on a sale.

Why a scholar should decide
  • Organised tawarruq is contested across jurisdictions; a qualified scholar should confirm the structure against the selected framework.
  • Independence of the commodity-sale counterparties and genuine constructive possession must be verified before relying on the assessment.
Sources cited
1
BNM, Shariah Resolutions in Islamic Finance (2nd ed.)
SAC resolution on tawarruq — 51st special meeting, 2005

The SAC of Bank Negara Malaysia resolved that the tawarruq arrangement is permissible subject to conditions.

2
AAOIFI Shari’ah Standard No. 30 — Monetization (Tawarruq)
Clauses on organised tawarruq
3
OIC International Islamic Fiqh Academy
Resolution 179 (19/5) on organised tawarruq, 2009

Real output, abridged. Assessments take 15–30 seconds.

IKIM
Built by IKIM

Tibyān HSG® is a Shariah verification and screening intelligence tool from the Institut Kefahaman Islam Malaysia. AI verifies; qualified scholars decide. It exists to help you ask better questions — not to replace scholars, advisors, or Shariah committees.

Questions

Before you ask

No. Tibyān HSG® produces an AI-drafted assessment that cites authoritative sources. It is meant to help you understand the issues and to take to a qualified advisor — it is not a binding ruling, and it never claims to be one.